A new version of the draft Murray-Darling Basin Plan put forward by the Murray Darling Basin Authority on Monday has drawn criticism from basin community representatives.RENEE THOMPSON August 9, 2012 4:24am
A new version of the draft Murray-Darling Basin Plan put forward by the Murray Darling Basin Authority on Monday has drawn criticism from several basin community representatives.
Instead of the previous 2750Gl target, the new draft proposes a water recovery target of between 2400Gl and 3200Gl, which would be adjusted based on water-saving measures.
Member for Rodney Paul Weller and the National Farmers’ Federation have added their voices to a number of state and federal leaders critical of the new draft.
On Tuesday, Mr Weller echoed Victorian Water Minister Peter Walsh’s comments that the MDBA’s latest draft did not sufficiently address the issues.
Mr Weller said the revised basin plan would cost hundreds of jobs in northern Victoria and was ‘‘unacceptable’’.
‘‘If you take another 300-400Gl of water out of northern Victoria, that is the ‘death knell’ for a number of communities,’’ he said.
‘‘That amount of water would produce enough milk for two milk factories.’’
NFF president Jock Laurie said the new draft failed to find the crucial balance called for by various irrigator groups, the community and last month’s Ministerial Council consensus document.
‘‘A month ago we welcomed the Ministerial Council’s directive to the authority that more attention be paid to ways to maximise the river systems’ efficiency through infrastructure, environmental works and measures and river operations,’’ he said.
‘‘The ministers called for an adjustment mechanism that would reduce the amount of water needed for the environment through improving the efficient use of water already in the system.
‘‘Investing in infrastructure, environmental works and measures and efficient river operations would make the water in the system work harder and, as a result, the sustainable diversion limit would decrease.
‘‘Yet from Monday’s report we can only conclude that this adjustment mechanism has been turned into an opportunity to take more water from the system, claiming that infrastructure would increase the sustainable diversion limit.
‘‘The NFF rejects using irrigation infrastructure to increase the limit.’’
However, Federal Water Minister Tony Burke, speaking to ABC Rural on Tuesday, said the new draft did include a sustainable adjustment mechanism that would allow irrigators to meet the same outcomes with less water taken away.
He said there was a ‘‘critical rule’’ to whether or not the figure was adjusted down to 2400Gl or up to 3200Gl.
‘‘The critical rule, if the number goes down, is you still have to be meeting the same environmental outcomes, and that allows for environmental works and measures to be there as a way of working effectively, in place of buybacks. ‘‘(And) if the number goes up, it can only be done in ways that don’t have negative impacts on communities.’’
Mr Burke said the latest plan was ‘‘an improvement on the last draft’’ while suggesting there was still work that needed to be done ‘‘until it’s right’’.
State governments have three weeks to respond to the latest draft.
Shepparton golfer Anne Pegg has earned herself a new nickname, Ace, after making a hole-in-one on the 12th hole at Shepparton Golf Club.
The Yarrawonga Pigeons will have to regroup after being dismantled by the Tigers in the OMFNL second semi-final.
Transition Tatura held a successful film festival, Communities Shaping the Future: a Day of Conversations and Films on Saturday, August 30.
Bowls is a sport which has been played in Echuca-Moama for a long time and Commonwealth Games silver medallist Claire Turley can tell you all about that.
Volunteers spent a day pegging out some of the final sites for this year’s Elmore Field Days.
Kyabram Angleers Club holds junior day
Mixed day for Seymour netballers, but B-grade side makes preliminary final.
On Saturday, for the first time in Jerilderie Football Club's history, the Dees won three consecutive senior premierships.
Heathcote pool users can now buy a rural pool pass and save.
Push for Cobram theatre continues after Yarrawonga cinema opens.
Norm Brennan at the helm for another term.
Now the Murray-Darling Basin Plan is enshrined in law, many opponents of the controversial plan to return irrigation water to the environment appear to have lost interest.
William Martiniello and Luke Morgan were the winner and runner-up in the GVFL Morrison Medal on Monday night.
Discover unbelievable local deals from local businesses every week in the Goulburn and Murray Valley area with Leapon.com.au!
Search properties for sale or rent across North Central Victoria and Southern NSW. Visit your local website for local homes....
Search for published and unpublished photos from McPherson Media Group newspapers and magazines. All our photos are available to purchase.
Place an advertisement in any one of McPherson Media Group's local newspapers.